← All posts

Software-Shaped, But Not Software

It's absolutely insane to watch Claude Code do a web search when asked to diagnose a Claude Code bug.

On the one hand, I get it, on both technical and existential levels.

1) The model doesn't necessarily have the information about itself in the training corpus. By its very nature, a model can't be trained on data about itself. You couldn't feed user manuals for Opus 5 into the Opus 5 training set. Time doesn't work that way.

2) If you asked me, "Eric, why does your knee hurt right now" (and it does), I don't have a clue. Just because I live in my own skin doesn't mean I understand how any of it works.

But, if I asked a doctor about a medical issue and they said "let me Google that real fast," I think I'd have an issue.

So, the dissonance with LLMs continues:

  • Software-shaped, but not software.
  • Human-shaped, but not human.

Interesting times, yo.

Eric Marcoullier · Obvious Startup Advice
Filed under

More Obvious Startup Advice

So you’d like to talk about startups…

Let’s Talk